Емблема «Просвіта»ПРОСВІТАЦИФРОВАЗнання · Люди · Майбутнє

HELLO, ELECTIONS. GOODBYE, DEMOCRACY?

Слово Просвіти, №02 за 2002 рік

The political year 2002 will differ from its predecessor primarily by the parliamentary elections and an even greater movement away from democracy. Although there are grounds for optimism (very insignificant ones), believes political scientist Volodymyr Polokhalo. The key event — the elections — will determine the paradigm not only of this year, but also of the near future. Analyzing the events from September to December and the first week of January, we have less and less hope for the democratic nature of these elections. We will not see a free expression of the will of citizens or compliance with standards inherent in European countries, including post-socialist ones. If we talk about elections, for example, in Poland, we can say that we are moving away from democracy. A classic said that democracy is a bad thing, but humanity has not yet invented anything better. A peculiarity of Ukrainian life is that society has not become an independent political author. Citizens have not shown themselves to be the force that determines the character of political power. That is why Volodymyr Lytvyn, without embarrassment, says that 25% of voters always support the government — whatever it may be. And this is not about its effectiveness or lack of competitiveness — it is trusted anyway. This means that a critical mass of civil society has not formed in Ukraine. In the state, undisguised pre-election campaigning is being conducted, the law on elections is not working, although this is the basic law at this stage. What then to say about how this will happen in March? The infamous administrative resource is an everyday reality — this is firstly. And secondly — the political culture of the Ukrainian elites is undemocratic by all signs. It is only about holding onto power — not about renewal or rotation. Holding onto it primarily in the hands of the President, who is the main participant in the elections, albeit an illegitimate one. — One of the gloomy forecasts for the consequences of the elections is civil war. Can you agree with such a prediction? — A civil war in Ukraine has been going on for many years — at the top. Citizens, however, are not fighting among themselves. But the nature of the competition between political elites has all the signs — murders, blackmail, the dirtiest compromising material, and this can be called a small civil war. It will not grow into a big one — Ukrainian society is not a society of the dissatisfied. Paradoxically, this is a society of the satisfied. Dissatisfaction can have different types — of the democratic part of citizens, this leads to the self-organization of society, mechanisms of pressure on the government, etc. There is passively democratic dissatisfaction — when a person would still like changes for the better, but is not active in expressing these political intentions. Finally, radical or lumpen dissatisfaction, to which politicians like Vitrenko or Symonenko appeal in Ukraine. But none of these expressions of dissatisfaction is distinct enough to cause social conflict. Our society is conservatively stable with pronounced passive citizenship. — So, after the elections, the West will finally give up on Ukraine. — It has already done so. Ukraine has established itself in the West as an undemocratic country — with a corrupt political elite that is moving away from Europe. To shake this image or somehow remove the negativity index, it will take many years; today's leaders are not capable of this. But they do not care, by the way. Finally, we have the image of a state in which the rule of law does not prevail. This is established both at the level of mass media and at the level of assessments by foreign politicians. I cannot find positive reviews about Ukraine in the foreign press. In the post-Soviet space, presidential authoritarianism is being established. In Kazakhstan, Belarus, Russia — Ukraine is no exception. From the point of view of commonality and the nature of trends, development prospects, Ukraine is very close to Russia — by 90%. But Russian authoritarianism has clear national signs, Russian people are consolidated around a national idea in a wide spectrum — from society to elites. From the right to the left, from Zyuganov to Zhirinovsky. The Ukrainian political elite, however, differs in that it is not consolidated in this sense. Clan interests prevail over national ones. And yet, it seems to me that there is a certain chance for democratic development. I still hope that there will be a non-left democratic opposition in parliament. Although I do not know who it will consist of. Perhaps, although it is unlikely, some democratic metamorphoses will take place with Yushchenko, perhaps Yulia Tymoshenko's bloc will get into parliament. So far, for all her radicalism, she demonstrates democratic symptoms inherent in the non-left opposition. Or, perhaps, some social-democratic metamorphoses will take place with Moroz. Otherwise, there will be a homogeneous parliament, which the President wants. It is about the succession of power — whether it will be from Kuchma to Kuchma or from Kuchma to Lytvyn, Medvedchuk or Kinakh — it does not matter. Lyudmyla PUSTELNYK Drawing by O. Yevtushenko

«Слово Просвіти», CC BY 4.0; machine translation from Ukrainian by Prosvita.Digital · PDF у Вікісховищі ↗ · Машинний переклад

Емблема «Просвіта»Просвітянин