Емблема «Просвіта»ПРОСВІТАЦИФРОВАЗнання · Люди · Майбутнє

Freedom of speech or empty talk?

Слово Просвіти, №02 за 2012 рік

in the investigation of the high-profile Gongadze case. It is impossible to imagine freedom of speech without free access for the public, primarily its representatives — journalists, to information. But, despite the adoption of the law on access to public information, the situation has not improved. More than 30 different cases of obstruction of the lawful professional activities of journalists and restrictions on access to information were officially recorded. Over the past year, an increase in censorship has been noted; it is being purposefully carried out by government structures both in the capital and in the regions. A characteristic example is Kharkiv, where opposition programs disappeared from television broadcasts. An indirect manifestation of censorship is the lack of pluralism in the media, in particular, on television, Photo by Petro Antonenko the hushing up by the majority of channels of important, but unpleasant for the authorities, topics: the trial of Yu. Tymoshenko, the falling ratings of the Party of Regions, the offensive against the rights and freedoms of citizens, important statements by politicians of Western countries, in particular the EU regarding the state of democracy in Ukraine. The main TV channels sluggishly report on serious socio-economic problems as well, although they worry millions of citizens. The fact that the media behave almost identically indicates that they are being “conducted” from government offices, and there is also self-censorship by media managers who react to “general trends.” Therefore, there is nothing to be happy about: we remain in the “hundred-something” places in world freedom of speech rankings. One would like some positivity, but one finds it according to the proverb “If there was no happiness, then misfortune helped.” Positivity was sought collectively in countering negativity: the final report mentioned the conducting of campaigns by journalistic and other non-governmental organizations to promote the law on access to information and amendments to the law on information, as well as the consolidation of the journalistic community — several media organizations united into the Ukrainian Media Association, and the Independent Media Trade Union of Ukraine began to overcome the crisis and revive regional organizations. On November 23, all media organizations of Ukraine united for the first time to hold a joint action against impunity for the murders of journalists. But all these actions are, as they say, “out of grief,” because there is nowhere left to retreat. It is encouraging that the Ukrainian authorities have finally entered into a dialogue with the journalistic community. How sincere this is and whether they are ready for progress in the sphere of freedom of speech — time will tell. For example, how effective will the order of the Minister of Internal Affairs be that the police should facilitate professional journalistic activity, rather than smashing TV cameras and voice recorders. At the press conference, a discussion unfolded about the effectiveness of media reports and the reaction to them from the authorities. This was also prompted by the well-known incident at President Yanukovych’s pre-New Year press conference, when he answered a question from a journalist of “Ukrainska Pravda” regarding his luxurious life at the state’s expense in Mezhyhirya by saying that this was, allegedly, an interference in his private life, although the question concerned “private life” at non-private public funds. The answer of the First Deputy Prosecutor General Rinat Kuzmin to the question of why the prosecutor’s office does not react to media materials about corruption of civil servants also echoes this. To which Kuzmin suggested that journalists provide the prosecutor’s office with materials and documents about these facts, and then law enforcement agencies would take up the checks. And this is despite the fact that the same “Ukrainska Pravda,” other websites, and some independent media published dozens of materials throughout 2011 about the luxurious life of the country’s leaders, dubious deals of government members, and other high-ranking officials. They published them, relying on numerous documents. So what is the reaction of law enforcement agencies? Tetyana Kotyuzhynska, President of the Association of Media Lawyers and expert of the National Union of Journalists, answered in detail. It turns out that a norm has long existed in our legislation that for the prosecutor’s office, the police, and other relevant bodies, media materials can be grounds for an inspection, and in case of necessity, for the initiation of criminal cases. They can, but not necessarily. That is, the prosecutor’s office may react, or it may not. True, Ms. Kotyuzhynska noted, media organizations have already developed a draft of amendments to the legislation, by which law enforcement agencies will be obliged to react to media reports. The proposals have been submitted to deputies, it is up to the parliament. For now, as they used to say, the writer (or journalist) “writes a little,” the reader “reads a little.” And not a single reaction to what is written, neither from the authorities, nor from the hero of the publications, nor from the readers themselves. Complete freedom of empty talk… Materials prepared by Petro ANTONENKO The most authoritative non-governmental organizations in the information sphere of Ukraine summed up the activities of our media for 2011. They were announced at a press conference at UNIAN by the heads of the organizations: Viktoriya Syumar — Executive Director of the Institute of Mass Information, Oksana Romanyuk — Head of the Ukrainian representative office of the international human rights organization “Reporters Without Borders,” Nataliya Ligachova — Editor-in-Chief of the “Telekrytyka” portal, Yuriy Lukanov — Head of the Independent Media Trade Union. A joint final statement “Freedom of Speech in Ukraine: 2011” was announced, which, in addition to the named organizations, was also signed by the “Stop Censorship!” movement, the Ukrainian Media Association, which includes the Institute of Media Law, Internews-Ukraine, and the Commission on Journalistic Ethics. The main point in the first sentence of the statement: “During 2011, a deterioration of freedom of speech was observed in Ukraine.”

«Слово Просвіти», CC BY 4.0; machine translation from Ukrainian by Prosvita.Digital · PDF у Вікісховищі ↗ · Машинний переклад

Емблема «Просвіта»Просвітянин