Сторінка · с. 2сторінка оригіналу ↗
Nostalgia for the Imperial Whip
Слово Просвіти, №12 за 2012 рік
It is by no means a coincidence that, with an interval of a few days, two events took place at a popular media venue in the capital — the UNIAN agency — which can only be described as an outright anti-Ukrainian sabbath. The “heroes” of the first event “showed up” at the second as well, which only confirmed the impression of a coordinated campaign. The presentation of the book by the scandalously famous Oles Buzyna, “The Resurrection of Malorossiya,” was presented under the guise of nominating the author for the 2013 National Shevchenko Prize. This primitive and at the same time pushy anti-Ukrainian “historicism” is a topic for a separate conversation. For now, let us talk about another presentation of the same ilk. About a roundtable on the occasion of the release of a book by the well-known historian, Academician Petro Tolochko. And this book is in Russian, its title is “Ukraine in an Orange Interior.” Petro ANTONENKO Neither the author nor the participants of the discussion hid the fact that while constantly digressing into the past, the events of recent years are being emphasized. The essence lies in the ideological, or if you will, even agitational orientation of the book. So what is its basis? Academician P. Tolochko noted that after Ukraine gained independence, the emphases in the understanding of our history changed sharply. If earlier its ideologization prevailed, then later the time for mythologization arrived. We seem to have two Ukrainian histories: one is shared with Russia and Belarus, the second is shared with Poland and the West. Further, the academician repeated his well-known theses that not everything was so bad in Ukraine during the times of its inclusion in the Russian Empire. Speaking about the present, Tolochko noted that he is a supporter of eastern, that is, pro-Russian integration. Because the western, European one is more complicated for Ukraine: “The path to Europe is not economic integration, but civilizational. On this path, we will have to say goodbye to many of our values.” Well, it is stated frankly: Russian-Asian values are closer to some. Academician Tolochko proposes three benchmarks. First — it is necessary to stop “ethnicizing” historical processes, because there were different ethnic groups on our land. Second — to introduce a “zero” ideological option. This will stop the confrontation along the East-West vector, in particular the war of monuments and slogans, and will smooth out ideological conflicts. Third — to introduce a federal structure of the state, which supposedly corresponds to the historical experience of Ukraine. The general idea is reconciliation, tolerance, multiculturalism, all this, of course, within the framework of Ukrainian statehood, which the academician supposedly does not deny. But other participants of the roundtable were more frank and less academic. Among them were many people quite well-known in certain circles as carriers of certain ideas. Thus, political scientist Mykhailo Pohrebinskyi stated that, according to new polls, as many as 47% of our citizens supposedly want to enter into a union with Russia and Belarus. And in general, the speaker noted, “we were heading in the wrong direction. And the current government is not drawing conclusions either.” The participants of the presentation, supporters of the current government and its course, expressed many critical words addressed to this government, saying that it is not pro-Russian enough. Then Heorhii Kriuchkov took the floor. Yes, the same one, one of the leaders of the Communist Party of Ukraine and the party faction in previous convocations of parliament. This time he was introduced as a “full member of the Academy of Security, Defense and Law and Order Problems,” Russia, Moscow. The passages of the Russian representative speak for themselves: people at the end of the 1980s and the beginning of the 90s succumbed to the temptation of a sweet life, but they did not want such a thing in the state. (I will note that they really did not want such a thing in a state ruled by communists and post-communists). It is a crime to judge history. The new government promised the Russian language as the second state language, a union with Russia, “de-Banderization” — none of this exists. Volodymyr Kornilov, director of the Ukrainian branch of the Moscow Institute of CIS Countries, stated that it is necessary to recommend Tolochko’s new book as a textbook for Ukrainian schools in order to “counter what is dangerous in Ukrainian textbooks.” Of course, the first timid attempts to open and show us our Ukrainian history are considered “dangerous.” The speakers openly felt nostalgia for the communo-empire and the “disintegration” of the Soviet Union. As at the presentation of “Buzyna-ism,” blogger Oleksandr Chalenko popped up: “Western Ukrainians are a different people. I do not want to live with them in one country.” The topic was continued by journalist Volodymyr Skachko with a series of hysterical questions: “Is the flag of Ukraine yellow and blue? Is the trident the Coat of Arms of Ukraine? Let us renounce the ethnonym ‘Ukrainian’! We are Malorossians.” There was something to rejoice about for another guest from Moscow — Kostiantyn
«Слово Просвіти», CC BY 4.0; machine translation from Ukrainian by Prosvita.Digital · PDF у Вікісховищі ↗ · Машинний переклад
