Емблема «Просвіта»ПРОСВІТАЦИФРОВАЗнання · Люди · Майбутнє

IVAN DZIUBA'S INTELLECTUAL RESISTANCE

Слово Просвіти, №25 за 2011 рік

Mykola TSYMBALIUK. In the Congregation Hall of NaUKMA, besides students, lecturers, and journalists, quite a few authoritative figures gathered that evening, almost the entire intellectual elite of Kyiv. There were not, and of course could not be, many of the people's deputies there, nor one of the representatives of the authorities — Tabachnyk. Two chapters out of the seven in Ivan Mykhailovych's new work are devoted to this odious gray figure. Although, frankly speaking, the participants of the discussion paid less attention to the “cockroach crawling on our land” than to the practice and development of Russian imperial chauvinism in the context of the spread of Ukrainophobic sentiments in the state. Yurii SHAPOVAL, Doctor of Historical Sciences, who could not be present at the event, sent the text of his speech. “It is quite clear,” he writes, “that Ivan Mykhailovych is doomed to failure in his attempts to convince a conscious ignoramus, at times a boor, a supporter of Catherine II and a deep ‘expert’ on what he calls ‘Ukrainian fascism’ (referring to the Kuchma-era, and now Yanukovych-era minister Tabachnyk — Auth.). No one will ever convince people of this type. And there is no need to. They should not have been allowed into power, which supposedly identifies itself as Ukrainian.” Developing Y. Shapoval's thesis, Volodymyr MORENETS, Doctor of Philological Sciences, professor at NaUKMA, does not share this point of view. He noted that, proceeding from different strategies for the existence of reasonable ideas, there are Socratic dialogues in the world. They, in particular, assume that you must convince your interlocutor. The author of “Nagnitannia moroku” (The Thickening of Darkness) can undoubtedly be credited with his famous “Internationalism or Russification?” (1965) as the first such attempt. Is this not the first brick of Ukrainian identification, where a scientific approach was applied? In the life of any nation, this problem is one of the fundamental ones, because a blurred identity sooner or later leads to radicalism, to orthodoxy. And the opinion of intellectuals in this field counts for a lot. In every society, there are always individuals who are listened to. But there are only a few with encyclopedic abilities. In the person of Ivan Dziuba, we see just such a person. It is no coincidence that he headed the publication of the Encyclopedia of Modern Ukraine. But in the presented book, Yevhen HOLOVAKHA, Doctor of Philosophical Sciences, deputy director of the Institute of Sociology of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine, saw that Dziuba is also a sociologist. “Pay attention,” he noted, “in many articles there are many categories and problems that are exceptionally important for modern sociology. I am talking about identity, about historical memory, about the transformation of society, about democratic processes. Perhaps this is most important not so much for Ukraine as for the world community. Especially regarding tolerance and xenophobia of various kinds.” Ivan Dziuba in the book, of course, pays primary attention to Ukrainophobia. And those numerous arguments he operates with cannot leave indifferent even the staunch opponents of Ukrainianness, or even its unconscious enemies. But on the condition that the polemic is conducted by intellectuals who know the essence of the problem from the beginning, from long ago, and ending with the present day. Of course, Tabachnyks, with their ridiculous claims to some intellect, cannot be convinced. Just like the government or the president. But the polemic of people like Ivan Dziuba sows deep ideas, prepares a reliable soil on which Tabachnyks will not appear in the future. Yurii SHCHERBAK, a writer, public figure, and diplomat, called on Ukrainians not to focus on the “sour cabbage soup” of mediocre Tabachnyk-style preparation. One should not exaggerate the importance of grayness, which tries by any means to show its significance. It is just a retranslator. Short-sighted, aggressive, pathologically ambitious, infinitely immoral and cynical in his methods, a puppet in someone else's hands (albeit well-paid). But behind him stand two truly fierce, terrible, decisive enemies of Ukraine capable of anything. These are Vladimir Putin, Prime Minister of the Russian Federation, and Kirill Gundyaev, Patriarch of the Russian Orthodox Church. And each in his own way wants to solve the problem of Russia's inevitable collapse. They understand that for them, Ukraine is the last salvation. What neither the Russian tsars, nor Lenin, nor Stalin, nor Brezhnev managed to do, they hope to do. They will stop at nothing. Although, like their predecessors, they have false illusions. Behind Moscow's aggressive attacks against the unity of the Ukrainian nation and state, the attempt to plant the Trojan horse of bilingualism, one must have the courage to see the real picture. Therefore, as long as books like Ivan Dziuba's appear, the people of Ukraine will not be blind and indifferent. In “Nagnitannia moroku” — said Volodymyr PANCHENKO, Doctor of Philological Sciences, professor at NaUKMA — the genesis and continuity of imperial ideas are presented. And this is a very interesting aspect of this study. Let us recall an episode from the history of Russian nationalism — Lesia Ukrainka's letter from 1905, which she wrote from St. Petersburg: “How I do not want to return to this Black Hundreds Kyiv!”. Even in those times, the empire turned Kyiv into a den of the Black Hundreds. And everything that Ivan Dziuba sets out in his articles, reflecting on the problem, operating with quotes from the 19th century, gives the impression that they are taken from the 21st century, from the Internet. So great is the similarity of what is happening now in Ukraine. By the way, this reveals not only the encyclopedic education of the author, but also his perfectly honed art of quoting, the art of hints, very transparent, when the quote itself speaks for itself in such a way that there is, in fact, nothing to add. As for the sent “Cossacks”, for intelligent people, there are more than enough facts in the actions of the authorities for unmistakable conclusions. I think that few people have doubts about the appearance of... Contemporaries called Serhii Yefremov, an academician of the Ukrainian Academy of Sciences, a well-known scientist, and an unsurpassed Ukrainian publicist, the “conscience of the Ukrainian nation”. At the heart of such high public recognition were not only Yefremov's virtues as a person, but also his high intellect, and his unwavering life and creative position in defending human and national interests. These words had to be heard regarding Ivan Dziuba at the presentation of his new book “Nagnitannia moroku: vid chornosotentsiv pochatku XX stolittia do ukrainofobiv pochatku stolittia XXI” (The Thickening of Darkness: From the Black Hundreds of the Early 20th Century to the Ukrainophobes of the Early 21st Century). This publication was released a few days ago by the “Kyiv-Mohyla Academy” Publishing House. position of the aforementioned minister of non-Ukrainian education. Or the very strange behavior of the special service of Ukraine led by Khoroshkovskyi during the events of May 9 in Lviv. This is an obvious provocation. But for whom, for whose interests does it work? There are many other examples that force one to think about the export of "little Cossacks," as well as agents of influence who work here, in modern Ukrainian politics, but serve the interests of another state. Thus, internal Turks, as Drahomanov wrote, they are alive, they are working, and this must be talked about because it is extremely important. There is another factor when it comes to the reasons for why we have such a painful situation. Panchenko quoted the words of Dziuba, which he never wrote, but once said. Words that could not help but be remembered: "But the nation does not exist!". He understood this thought in such a way that our nation is under-formed, beaten many times, and these words belong to the category of diagnosis. A very difficult, but necessary diagnosis. We must tell ourselves the truth, understand ourselves better without outside explanations. Because without a clear awareness of what is happening to us, we will not be able to adequately respond to the current challenges of the world. Therefore, the book by I. M. Dziuba is a fact of intellectual resistance, intellectual opposition. This is what is extremely important for current Ukrainian society. Ihor LOSIEV, Candidate of Philosophical Sciences, Professor at NaUKMA, aptly noted that Ukrainians should not harbor illusions that Russian chauvinism in Ukraine, Black Hundredism, can be defeated only by intellectual efforts. Although the role of Ivan Dziuba's publicism here is hard to overestimate. However, among those people who work among us and against

«Слово Просвіти», CC BY 4.0; machine translation from Ukrainian by Prosvita.Digital · PDF у Вікісховищі ↗ · Машинний переклад

Емблема «Просвіта»Просвітянин