Сторінка · с. 2сторінка оригіналу ↗
Reflections of a philosopher
Слово Просвіти, №41 за 2011 рік
Conclusion. Beginning on page 1 INDECENT PLEASURES OF POWER
good”. In 2010, everything was different. Now, from the depths of souls, everything dark and ugly was rising. It was an orgy of aggressive revenge, and with their entire appearance and behavior, the newcomers were saying: “We have ‘done’ you and we will ‘have’ you.” Unlike the messianic eschatology of the Maidan, the spirit of the Apocalypse hovered here. And it is precisely now that it has blossomed in full bloom. At the end of the article, I will return to the description of this atmosphere, all the “excesses of obscenity” with which it is saturated. For now, I will touch only upon those of their manifestations that are directly related to the trials of Yu. Lutsenko and Yu. Tymoshenko and which, in turn, are the consequences of the destruction of the foundations of an independent judicial system. Often, these trials are called “Kafkaesque” due to their absurdity and the groundlessness of the accusations, but this comparison is superficial. After all, the main pathos of F. Kafka’s novel “The Trial” consists in fixing the “obscene reverse side of the Law” (S. Žižek), and the Law as such, since it always contains within itself the presumption of guilt of each of us and the possibility of unjust Violence against each of us. The current Ukrainian justice system, in the person of the Pechersk Court, simply substitutes the Law (with all its “reverse sides”) with an Obscene Sadistic Orgy. In this flaunting of obscenity, the usual legal casuistry no longer plays any role. Moreover, within the framework of shows like the “Vovk-show”, “Kirieiev-show” or “Frolova-show”, it is mocked just as much as the persons of the defendants. Why are Stalinist trials mentioned so obsessively under these conditions? Because the latter were also a triumph of obscenity in its pure form. The obscenity consisted in the imitation of a judicial proceeding; back then, the court was turned into a spectacle, a farce, where everyone played their assigned role — prosecutor Vyshynskyi, the witnesses, the defendants themselves, who participated in a phantasmagoric scenario of self-incrimination. Finally, the Main Spectator — Joseph Vissarionovich, who loved to watch from his personal chair this spectacle staged especially for him, receiving all possible pleasures, including aesthetic ones, while doing so. (If we have already touched upon this obscene variety of leader-style “voyeurism”, then a comparison of the current political figures with the “Leader of the Peoples” allows us to reveal an interesting similarity in the propaganda rhetoric that “justifies” all these sadistic orgies. Stalin had a grand program of building socialism through “industrialization and collectivization”, Yanukovych has “reforms” as an instrument for entering a “bright European future”. Joseph Vissarionovich had the ideologeme of the “intensification of class struggle and the search for ‘enemies of the people’” who hinder this “movement forward”, Viktor Fedorovych has a “merciless fight against corruption” and a terrible oath to punish everyone who resists this “cleansing of power and society”. In Stalinist propaganda, there was the thesis “When you chop wood, chips fly” or “It is better for a hundred innocent people to suffer than to miss one enemy”, and in the propaganda pearls of the domestic authorities — “Surely the case of some Yu. Tymoshenko cannot hinder our entry into the European community?!”. Is this newly minted ideological junk not related to the modern propaganda machine of the Ukrainian authorities with the “high” classical examples of the Stalinist era? And is it not this similarity of political styles that prompts those particularly sensitive to this “kinship of obscenities” to erect monuments to Stalin? But more on that a little later.) I repeat, the situation in the high-profile cases of Yurii Lutsenko and Yuliia Tymoshenko is very similar. One difference is the level of the main actors of this performance. For example, the old-school lawyer Vyshynskyi was simply a Cicero compared to the prosecutorial cadres of the domestic “vintage” with their amazing mixture of inarticulateness and legal illiteracy. But if one abstracts from these differences, the similarity to the trials of 1937 is simply striking. Complete contempt for determining the Truth during the trial and the legal essence of the matter, an a priori verdict written from above, and an obscene aftertaste of the triumph of sadistic impulses — this is what links those distant Stalinist trials with the high-profile cases of Yu. Lutsenko and Yu. Tymoshenko. After all, in reality, a trial of political opponents is a typical case of “lowering” in a prison camp, and all the nuances of these trials are an endless multiplication of such ritual humiliations of political opponents. For example, it is pointless to look in the legal plane for an answer to the question of why Yurii Lutsenko has been kept in custody without a verdict for eight months already. But this answer can be easily obtained from an analysis of general obscenity, an understanding of the essence of “obscene pleasures”, among which “Lady Revenge” occupies a privileged place and in which sadistic repetitions play a primary role. (By the way, in the works of the Marquis de Sade, victims are tormented by winding up a repetitive, monotonous mechanism of torture. It is precisely such a monotone that we can observe in the case of Yu. Lutsenko. The keyword of these tortures is the mechanism of refusal to any request of the defendant, and refusal without any meaningful consideration. Refusals to change the preventive measure, refusals to recuse judges and prosecutors, refusals to provide normal medical treatment, etc. By the way, Lutsenko’s hunger strikes and illnesses have greatly increased the possibility of these sadistic abuses.) The situation with Tymoshenko is even more telling. In her case, we have the same set of techniques. The same senseless detention. The same series of refusals (along with the refusal to change the preventive measure) without any legal grounds for doing so. The situation with Yuliia Tymoshenko’s sudden illness and all the court’s sadistic games around this event (refusal to admit her personal doctor, another refusal to change the preventive measure) turn this trial into a “clone” of the trial of Yu. Lutsenko. Here everything repeats itself like in a bad dream. However, Yulia’s case gives the organizers of the entire process additional opportunities also because she is a woman. Moreover, a striking and even, as her “professional” persecutor I. Bohoslovska said, “charismatic” woman. In general, the “gender” aspect of “Tymoshenkophobia” in both men and women is a very interesting topic for a social psychoanalyst. (I will not touch upon it seriously, although it is already superficially obvious that the matter here is a combination of elementary envy and primitive male sexism.) But now I want to draw attention to what additional opportunities for sadistic games the fact of the accused belonging to the female sex provides. After all, for the entire army of “Tymoshenkophobes”, it is so great to see this woman, recognized as one of the most attractive and sexy politicians in the post-Soviet space, in a queue for prison slop. When I hear the chanting of paid representatives of the plebs, led by the head of the Military Union, Mr. O. Kalashnikov (whose military spirit is especially strong when it is necessary to beat a young journalist), “Yulia to the bunks! Yulia to the bunks!”, I understand the secret desire of this plebs. This desire completely coincides with the desire of the authorities — to receive pleasure from the humiliation of a beautiful, confident and “glamorous” woman, to see her trampled and literally smeared “against the wall”. Here, the obscene pleasure is analogous to what the crowd felt during public executions of people once close to power, whether in the Middle Ages, during the Jacobin dictatorship, or during the Stalinist “purges”. The mechanism of this pleasure is always one and the same: the spectacle of the overthrow of a once all-powerful ruler into Nothing, into a pile of garbage. Such an overthrow caresses the “Ego” of a person from the crowd; it makes them more significant. An obscene, “nasty” joy arises from the same mixture of envy and revenge against the successful, against those who stand out from this crowd. (By the way, this mechanism was accurately revealed by A. S. Pushkin in his famous commentary on why the crowd loves to read “exposures” of the flaws of the great. “He is worthless — just like us, he is filth”
— just like us” — this is the foundation of this obscene joy, noted by the poet. To see the expression of such pleasure, it is enough to read some comments by representatives of single-celled social zombies that accompany news reports about the progress of the trial of Y. Tymoshenko. All these repetitive, monotonous messages about “Yulka-the-thief,” who robbed Ukraine with Pasha Lazarenko and for whom, finally, the time has come to follow her patron to the bunk. In general, all such internet “graffiti” have a deeply anal character. The internet here is like a toilet, where mental and verbal waste is dumped. In its character of obscenity, it is no different from inscriptions on fences with words known to everyone. And as for the trial of Yulia, this obscenity takes on the features of infantile sadism, which prompts a child to tear the wings off insects. In this sense, a passage by one user is characteristic, stating that “we will skin Yulia like a frog and see what kind of princess she is.” I am citing all this filth with only one purpose — to demonstrate that our entire public and political life is overflowing with it, filled by perverts of all stripes who are dragging the country into the tailspin of their dirty orgies. To characterize the social atmosphere of the 1990s, the word “bespredel” (lawlessness) was often used. This word is almost a synonym for the concept of “excess”; indeed, now we can observe a kind of déjà vu of that time. The only difference is that the aforementioned lawlessness existed in some “parallel reality,” as if in the shadow of the public-political sphere. Now it has become the norm of political life, giving rise to all kinds of “excesses” that I already mentioned at the beginning of this article. After the destruction of all basic foundations of social life (the Constitution, the Court, the Parliament), a “go-ahead” was seemingly given to mock all other institutions, principles, and values. And in just a little more than a year of its rule, the current regime has provided all possible varieties of “excesses” of such mockery. Excesses that go beyond the “Sharikov-like” ignorance of high-ranking state officials. Excesses of Asian demonstrative luxury of consumption by these same individuals against the backdrop of economic degradation and the impoverishment of the population (with Mezhyhirya, helicopters, golden toilets). Excesses of lies and political demagoguery, which, like a veil, envelops this bacchanalia. (I have already mentioned the propaganda gibberish about democratic “reforms” and the “fight against corruption” in a situation of the formation of a typical police state.) Excesses of impunity. (Examples with all sorts of Landiks and other killer-majors, who demonstrate a savoring of the process of mocking the value of human life, are more than sufficient.) Excesses of disregard for legal norms and human dignity in our courts, which we have just spoken about. Excesses of the complete moral decay of the so-called elite (an example is the situation in the Ukrainian parliament, mostly turned into a gathering of immoral degenerates). Excesses of desecration of national history. (In this context, the appointment of the Ukrainophobe D. Tabachnyk as Minister of Education is a typical example of such mockery, some kind of “collective orgasm” of people of a certain sort from such national humiliation. And can the installation of monuments to Stalin and the legalization of Soviet red flags be interpreted any other way, are these not spits “in the mug” of the patriots of this country?) Excesses of blatant political smear campaigns (Ms. Bohoslovska is beyond competition here). Excesses of intimidation and the demonstration of force (the entire process of transferring Yulia Tymoshenko to the pre-trial detention center with hundreds of “Berkut” officers and the “duty” of dozens of buses with them near the opposition tents on Khreshchatyk will remain a model of this Orwellian “boot stamping on a human face”). The parade of these excesses can be multiplied infinitely; they all belong to a single style of thinking and political practices, behind which are the obscene games of those in power. These excesses tempt with their permissiveness, the reduction of the entire complexity of social existence to seizure and violence. They drag the entire country into their mad vortex and bring it closer to the zone of absolute evil. However, this evil is devoid of any halo of romantic demonization. The nature of this Evil lies in the absurdity of structurelessness, not in the excessive concentration of power in the hands of a Dictator. Therefore, a more accurate image of this Evil could be served not so much by torture chambers with prisoners (although they too), as by the image of a cesspool or a landfill. My favorite philosopher of the Soviet era, Merab Mamardashvili, in his poignant providentialism, called such social states an “anthropological catastrophe.” He used this term in relation to Soviet reality. However, this characterization is especially accurate regarding the processes that are taking place before our eyes. Under these conditions, the question remains logical: “Is there a way out of the hell of this anthropological catastrophe?” This philosopher said that one always returns from hell empty-handed. And the great Dante warned that at the entrance to hell, one must abandon all Hope. However, I continue to hope (perhaps foolishly) that this collective darkness will eventually dissipate. This hope is based on the fact that “systemic” metaphysical Evil does not leave people the slightest “clearance” where they could hide from it. But thanks to this persistence of its own, it simply annihilates, destroying itself. Oleksii SHEVCHENKO, Doctor of Philosophical Sciences, Kyiv. A frame from Stanley Kubrick’s film “Eyes Wide Shut”
«Слово Просвіти», CC BY 4.0; machine translation from Ukrainian by Prosvita.Digital · PDF у Вікісховищі ↗ · Машинний переклад
