Емблема «Просвіта»ПРОСВІТАЦИФРОВАЗнання · Люди · Майбутнє

LINGUISTIC-CULTURAL NATIONALISM IN THE PROCESS OF SHAPING PUBLIC OPINION

Слово Просвіти, №74 за 2000 рік

World civilization is entering a new phase of its development. Global processes show that the modern technocratic civilization is in the stage of a gradual transition into an informational one. Under such conditions it is necessary to rethink the basic principles of the ideology of Ukrainian nationalism, and the forms and methods of struggle for national interests. Let us ask the question: can an ideology oriented only toward agrarian and industrial forms of social organization unite the nation on the threshold of post-industrialism? Can the nationalist idea be popularized using only the methods of Prosvita that were developed a hundred years ago? Can a state be built without attention to the formation of public opinion, when almost half of society wishes for its destruction? My main idea is to substantiate that under conditions of the spread of mass communications and liberal democracy, mass consciousness will have an increasing influence on the political transformations of individual states as well as entire regions. The subject of the article is linguistic-cultural nationalism. Therefore I will try to prove that the formation of mass consciousness is today extremely necessary for preserving the integrity and independence of the state and for the attainment of power by the indigenous ethnos in Ukraine. The processes of state-building are impossible without the support of the overwhelming majority of society. Mass consciousness influences the formation of organs of power, which in turn form state policy. What do we have today? The absence of even fragmentary structuring not only in society but also in the political class leads to the confrontation in the state remaining at the level of uncertainty for almost seven years. The civilizational conflict in Ukraine has reached a dead end. For over seven years the Ukrainian state has been suffering from social, economic and civilizational contradictions. The postcolonial authorities have not understood the necessity of uniting the nation around the statehood idea and the processes of state-building. For them the Ukrainian idea has always been alien. The information field in the state is still not protected, methods of social management and the formation of mass consciousness are not used, and the mechanisms of socialization have been destroyed. In the communicative space, Westernized and Russian cultures compete. For Ukrainians, only an ethnographic niche is still allotted. Therefore society is divided almost in half according to cultural-civilizational orientations. In the political class, as in society, there is no consensus regarding the very expediency of the state's existence. Instead of working on legal and economic reforms and promoting the processes of state-building, at all levels of power a struggle is under way between opposing political, oligarchic and ideological groupings. As a result of the will of citizens, political forces with opposite ideological and political orientations come to power. Today Ukrainian society has not arrived at a stable awareness of itself as a fully separate and integral community; it has problems with identification, linguistic and cultural self-definition. Analyzing public opinion research, one can come to a sad conclusion: by political and socio-economic orientations, society is divided almost in half. This was largely caused by the fact that during the colonial past people were imposed distorted notions and stereotypes. For decades the people withstood the pressure of massive anti-Ukrainian propaganda in various forms. When Ukraine became independent, this pressure ceased, but in culture, the mass media and educational institutions, if an ideological vacuum did not form, then there is a very noticeable absence of purposeful state policy in this regard. For centuries the Ukrainian lands were peripheral within various states, which caused cultural decline and the lagging of everything Ukrainian behind modernization processes in all spheres of life. As a consequence, there is a significant problem of the "prestige" of the Ukrainian language and culture, which is reflected in a skeptical attitude of a considerable part of citizens toward statehood itself. Therefore a considerable part of ethnic Ukrainians renounces their own identity in favor of other languages and cultures. Potentially Ukraine is one of the powerful states of Europe. But in reality it can become such only on condition of uniting the nation around a national idea. And this is not only an ideological necessity; it concerns first of all the security of the state itself. The example of Belarus shows that there is a constant threat to the state under conditions of foreign culture dominating the consciousness of its citizens. Cultural annexation is sometimes more frightening than military-political annexation, because in this case society begins to perceive itself as part of the state whose culture is more attractive to it. Today the real agents of shaping the civilizational orientations of the public in Ukraine are Anglo-American and Russian cultures. Political uncertainty is becoming a hallmark of the Ukrainian state. Therefore, for example, the Ukrainian presi- AUGUST, No. 8 (74), 2000 YEAR dent initially speaks of the Russian vector of Ukrainian policy, then reorients toward Euro-Atlantic integration processes, and only in the last year of his presidential powers declares that "foreign policy must be pro-Ukrainian." Therefore the authorities first say that "the Ukrainian idea has not worked," and two years later throw all their efforts into creating the so-called program "Ukraine—2010," which is to become the conceptual basis of the national idea. Among the ideologies, as the latest elections showed, liberal and socialist ones prevail. Nationalist-democrats are supported by only about 18 percent of the public, and even those mostly in the western region of the state, and, let us face the truth, traditional nationalists are losing influence on society altogether. There are several reasons for this: 1) nationalists use outdated methods of propaganda and of influencing mass consciousness; 2) Soviet stereotypes have left in mass consciousness mostly a negative attitude toward the ideology of Ukrainian nationalism; 3) the negative experience of existence in an independent state, socio-economic problems are associated with the idea of Ukrainian statehood, Ukrainians have grown tired of long waiting for an improvement of living conditions, and now time is working no longer in favor of the Ukrainian idea. The 20th century is the century of the emergence and spread of global information communications. Developed countries are entering a new phase of civilizational development, which today is commonly called the post-industrial society. The information explosion has given rise to concepts of the "informatized society of the future." The mass media, in a figurative expression, are becoming the "fourth branch of power," whose influence keeps growing. With the creation of the worldwide computer network Internet, humanity is entering a new stage in the development of mass communications. An individual or a small community can become subjects of the communicative process. This opens new opportunities before nationalists. Processes of globalization and the accelerated growth of transnational corporations threaten national states with a new form of mobile, economic-spiritual imperialism, which ever more confidently seizes sales markets, imposes its rules of the game, values and worldview through the mass media and culture. Filtering of information concentrated mainly in the English-speaking world leads to the fact that post-socialist countries, on the one hand, are pushed away from established equal relations in the sphere of informatics and information exchange, and on the other hand, become the object of massive cultural and worldview expansion, and hence of the expansion of foreign capital. There exists a point of view that the economy of the future will rest mainly on information, and that information is becoming the main resource, which will dominate, displacing raw materials and energy to the second plan. Whoever controls information, the means of mass media and communication and information technologies, will control the consciousness of the overwhelming majority and will have unlimited power. In general, Western intellectuals believe that modern states, with the exception of superpowers, have weakened. Globalization has led to the situation where the current state is unable to exercise total control over its territorial, administrative, political and economic sovereignty. New rules of the game, which are imposed on subjects of international law by supranational structures, deprive the state of the possibility of performing its classical functions. Cultural uncertainty, especially in regions of civilizational fault lines (which include Ukraine as well), hinders the creation of "nation-states," since a culturally disunited ethnos cannot determine the identity of people who are connected in a virtual community. Newly formed states, trying to adapt Western political-science methods on their own soil, play by double rules, legitimate and illegitimate, and this leads to corruption and a crisis of state administration. Analysts believe that geopolitical transformations in the world may lead to a new fragmentation similar to the medieval one, a modern "feudalization" of states and superpowers. The correlation between the opposing and mutually dependent processes of globalization and general disintegration is almost impossible to calculate, but it seems that the world is moving toward a new imperialism, although the centers of geopolitical gravity may shift somewhat. These tendencies must be used for the benefit of Ukrainian nationalism. We must not defend ourselves against the imperial onslaught, but compete for leadership within the limits of our civilizational niche. Therefore, we now need a modernization of nationalist ideology, one that will not merely proclaim intentions but outline real mechanisms for integrating the nation, mobilizing it for the building of statehood, for competitive struggle in the world, for Ukrainian economic, informational and cultural expansion, if you like. Some will say that it is too early to talk about this, that such an ideology will not be rational and pragmatic. Perhaps that is indeed so, but who said that an ideology must be rational? It must perform the function of shaping mass consciousness, which is for the most part irrational and does not perceive complex logical schemes. New tasks and a new idea must harmoniously combine rationality and irrationality, pragmatism and idealism. It is necessary to find a reasonable balance between these opposite and at times incompatible notions. In this context, the words of Dmytro Korchynskyi come to mind: "Did we really have to struggle for so long for our own state in order to understand that what we actually need is a people." We have a state, but we do not have a full-fledged nation that would become the guarantor of the inviolability of its borders and sovereignty. Therefore, given what has been said above, nationalists today must think not so much about the conceptual or terminological definition of the nation as about the conceptual and methodological foundations of the mechanisms for its creation. To fulfill its historical mission, we must first integrate and mobilize the nation. Without this, conversations about the idea and the deed, about achieving certain goals, about the content of the very concept of the nation, will remain at the level of empty chatter. Regarding the methods of forming public opinion, one must remember that mass consciousness is emotional and irrational; propaganda methods require the use of clear, simple and understandable arguments that in an accessible form will show the public the ways to meet their basic needs. Propaganda must be massive, offensive and persuasive. One must once and for all abandon justifications and explanations. Whoever justifies himself is already half guilty. Only confidence and aggressiveness are perceived at the emotional level, which is the main one in communication with a mass audience. It is necessary, using all public relations technologies, to conduct a massive offensive on the mass media. We must achieve such a level of positioning that will ensure the constant presence of nationalist ideology in the information space of Ukraine and in global computer networks. In every normal state, mass communications perform important consolidating functions, supporting the unity of the linguistic and cultural integrity of society. Despite different political, ideological and economic orientations, the mass media are for the most part unanimous on issues concerning national interests. In Ukraine today such communication is absent. We have neither a state policy for protecting the information and cultural space, nor a single linguistic and cultural identity of citizens, nor a clear program for studying and shaping public opinion. Therefore, nationalists must attack the existing mass media and lobby for the processes of creating and protecting their own information space. In current conditions, without a struggle for mass consciousness it is impossible to effectively influence political processes in the state. In order to function effectively, implement the provisions of one's own program, take part in elections and win, to successfully shape mass consciousness and influence the electoral and civic behavior of voters, it is necessary to possess information both at the global and micro levels, feeling the needs of each individual segment of society. That is, to keep a finger on the pulse, to have information and to react instantly to the slightest changes: 1) in geopolitical transformations, especially in regions adjacent to Ukraine; 2) in the internal life of the state, including the personalities of various political, industrial, entrepreneurial and financial groupings; 3) in the personnel composition and personnel policy within the organization. Information is also needed about what is happening in the mass media, including even the yellow press. In general, it would be good to have the possibility of introducing total monitoring so that nothing interesting covered by the mass media escapes attention. One must constantly use the results of sociological research, and on issues that are insufficiently studied, conduct one's own surveys. It is necessary to have information on the demographic and socio-psychological characteristics of each electoral district (at the very least, the promising ones). It would be worthwhile to develop a kind of social, economic and political portrait of Ukraine as a whole and of each electoral district in particular. The point is not total control over society and the individual, but political forces that claim victory must pay due attention to information. Therefore, today it is necessary to create an information-analytical center, for example, on issues of mass communications and the study and shaping of public opinion in Ukraine. The functions of such a center could be:

«Слово Просвіти», CC BY 4.0; machine translation from Ukrainian by Prosvita.Digital · PDF у Вікісховищі ↗ · Машинний переклад

Емблема «Просвіта»Просвітянин