Seite · S. 2Originalseite ↗
The Search for the Best Model of Ukrainian Government
Слово Просвіти, №10 за 2017 рік
Society is becoming poorer and is ready to change the government in terms of individuals endlessly, without knowing exactly what system of government it should want. There is no single opinion, and it is impossible to reach an agreement because a different understanding of democracy and the state is needed. The crisis of Ukrainian statehood arose due to excessive enthusiasm for the process of democratizing the Soviet system of government with the help of foreign models and outside advice. This path has brought the state to a state of incredibly complex intertwining, delegation, and duplication of the powers of the so-called branches of government, turning the parliament into a sacred cow without fear, pity, or a master. The state is steadily losing functionality, and this is precisely what fatally affects the well-being and security of citizens. For the people, a good system of government is one that works cheaply and reliably for the benefit of citizens. Therefore, the search for the best model of government boils down to restoring the functionality of state structures of power. This is within the power of Ukrainian society, of people's democracy. One just needs to understand how and have a plan for change... Volodymyr FERENTS, Ivano-Frankivsk. To begin with, one should discard harmful stereotypes inherited from the USSR or imposed. The most harmful one is that the people delegate rights to elected officials who create state power on behalf of the people, who exchange powers among themselves, mutually limit each other, fight corruption, and as a result, such a state loses functionality and responsibility, is capable mainly of satisfying its own appetite, and reacts slowly to world threats. The second harmful stereotype is the attempt to carry out amateur, spontaneous public control of the government in terms of individuals without a rational plan and means for its correction and improvement. This is very similar to a depressive waste of the priceless time of personal life, playing a game with the bureaucracy that is impossible to win. Abuses in the system of government have only two causes: a failure of its functionality and non-observance of the principle of personal responsibility of people in power. It is worth not monitoring the actions of persons, but monitoring the actions of the government. The young, highly educated generation of Ukrainians, instead of looking for happiness in foreign lands, can and must create public structures of a modern type suitable for this purpose. For the evolutionary correction of the functions of the state machine, reasonable (not spontaneous), organized public action and one or two electoral periods, that is, 10-12 years, are sufficient. Everything depends on how many citizens accept the idea of a reasonable transformation of the state power system and on the determination to overcome the resistance of the higher bureaucracy — parasites on the people's budget. It is not difficult to guess that the main source of the growing failure of the state's functionality is the Ukrainian parliament. It writes laws, controls their execution, appoints the executive branch, judges, the CEC, carries out the distribution of resources, and sets expenses and salaries for itself and the officials dependent on it as it pleases. Parliamentarians are untouchable and are not responsible for the result of their activities. The unlimited, unaccountable functions of the parliament mostly limit and duplicate the functions of other structures of power, which brings disorder and stupor to the entire system of state power. What is the value of the monopolization and multiplication by the parliament of the so-called fight against corruption, even though this is an elementary function of the entire state machine! How to cure the parliament? It should not appoint the government — it can influence its activities with the help of laws; it should not approve the budget, which is executed not by it, but by the government. The parliament should not appoint judges, officials, and even more so — all sorts of supreme fighters against corruption. To control the integrity of the president, stimulate the execution of laws, and improve the state machine and justice, the parliament has a single, but most powerful tool — laws and laws again. The parliament cannot and should not have any other way of interacting with the government and the president, except for passing laws. No one should have a monopoly on the so-called legislative initiative — this is the right and duty of a citizen and an association of citizens, the president, and an official. No one should have the right to dissolve the parliament, but the people have the right to recall a people's deputy very quickly, according to a simple procedure defined by law, regardless of which community of voters they were elected from. This will increase the responsibility of the parliament. The process of elections and referendums should be ensured by an apolitical official, and not by politicized CECs and commissions created by those who are being elected. The term “representative power” is from the evil one, because every power represents the people, but power must be strictly functional. The function of the parliament should be strictly limited only to lawmaking. The power of organized public opinion and action, which will demand a radical change in the constitutional functions of the parliament, can return functionality to the parliament, but above all, this idea must become the leading one in the minds of Ukrainians. At the same time, the people do not have the right to entrust the changing of the Constitution to the adherents of the state machine, because the result will be the same or a hundred times worse. There is no need to believe the nonsense that the people cannot write a constitution because it is the business of academics of constitutional law. The Constitution is by no means a social contract between the people and the state, but the main law of the life of the people, and it must be written in simple folk language, be easily read by the common people, and be perceived unambiguously, without any interpretations. Any complications and ambiguities in the text of the Constitution will inevitably result in a failure of the functionality of power and will work against the interests of the people. What is the role of the president? In the modern world, it is vitally important for every nation to have a tool for rapid response to external and internal threats, responding powerfully and instantly with a single informational, economic, and military action, urgently and profitably changing the economy and the humanitarian sphere of society with a single goal — so that the well-being and security of citizens grow, or at least do not deteriorate. The responsibility of such a social tool must be the highest and personified. We are talking about the office of the president, which in the informational, globalized world should tend toward monarchy in proportion to the growth of threats coming from the world. If the parliament is limited only to the creation of laws, no one will believe the fairy tales about the usurpation of power by the president, because he will have the power to perform the main functions of the state and will be personally responsible for a tangible result — the well-being and security of society. This responsibility must be the highest; it must be defined by law. To fulfill the function of a single personified center for making rapid and vital decisions for society, the president must be fully responsible for the formation and actions of the government, solely and therefore responsibly appoint and dismiss justice officials and judges, and represent the state in relations with the world. The president must possess the gift of an ideologue of statehood and an exponent of the goal of civil society.
What is the role of the government? The government as the executive power must be an absolutely apolitical, purely functional instrument for achieving the universal goal of society — the growing well-being and security of the state's population. Changing and improving the government can be carried out only by appointing more effective officials. The government is guided by laws and the universal need of society for security and growing well-being and carries out the instructions and orders of the president. The head of government is outside of politics and performs the functions of a manager who organizes the activities of the bureaucracy, approves the state budget, and is personally responsible for its thrifty use exclusively for achieving the goal of society. The salary of government officials cannot be higher than the average salary in society and must grow in the order established by law, in proportion to the growth of the well-being and security of citizens.What is the role of justice? Justice must serve only the will of the law. A judge cannot be appointed by a collective decision, that is, irresponsibly. The appointment of a judge takes place only under the personal responsibility of the president. He also has the right and obligation to personally and urgently correct a mistake — to immediately dismiss an unworthy judge or other law enforcement official. The prosecutor's office is a redundant structure, inconsistent with the principle of state functionality. Lawbreakers must be accused in the name of the people by people's defenders of the law equal among themselves — prosecutors appointed by the president. The hierarchy of prosecutors is devoid of meaning and harmful to their independence, and their number must meet the needs of the courts in proportion to the number of lawyers. Lawyers are appointed by the president similarly to the appointment of prosecutors. Every citizen must have the right to defend themselves and members of their family in court personally, and also additionally use the services of a lawyer, paid for from the state treasury only for persons with an income lower than the average in the state.What is the role of education and information? People's democracy begins and ends with the issue of education and information. If information is completely controlled by a private owner of the means of its dissemination, and education is controlled simultaneously by parliament, the government, and foreign grantors — people's democracy is impossible. The entire information space and means of disseminating information must be constantly monitored by public organizations for the purpose of promoting people's democracy with the right to immediately stop violations in the order determined by law. Education aims at the upbringing and training of an active citizen capable of supporting people's democracy with the goal of achieving success, well-being, freedom, and security in the homeland. In conditions of globalization, society primarily protects the education system and the information space so as not to allow external exploitation of its demographic and intellectual potential and corruption of the highest power. It is in these areas of society that the struggle of state interests takes place, and the well-being and identity of citizens are protected. Without an active people's democracy, primarily through demands to strengthen the protective functions of the state, the state itself will not be able to cope with this. Because the state is very vulnerable to external financial and information influences. Corruption occurs only for the purpose of surrendering the foundations of identity and the information space, and subsequently creating conditions of external financial dependence. All other types of corruption are derivative and secondary. People's democracy will not be able to overcome the corruption of the state machine without protecting the information space, education, and finances of the state from external influence. Of course, this must be a people's democracy of a higher qualification level — systematically acting public organizations and parties.What is the role of a public organization and a political party? A public organization cannot have any other goal than achieving the goal of society — the growing well-being, freedom, and security of the lives of citizens. The organization carefully monitors the state of functionality of the state and mobilizes society to maintain the high capacity of the state machine to satisfy the needs of society and citizens. A party is the same public organization that performs the mission of people's democracy more professionally, constantly, and with a perspective of positive development and improvement of the goal of society. Parties are initiated as public movements of people's democracy, developing to a higher professional level of public activity. If it were not for the global fashion for party politics, one could do without parties. Modern parties must get rid of fundamentally erroneous ambitions of gaining power for the purpose of executing programs in conditions of a stable political system of power. The true, useful role of parties for society is the preparation and promotion into elective and government structures of qualified and conscientious citizen-individuals who are capable of performing the role of deputy and official in the best possible way and understand the work of the single state organism. If a party has not been able to justify the expectations of society or has not realized its programmatic obligations, it de facto always descends to the level of an ordinary public organization or ceases its activity.What is the role of a citizen? No one can force a citizen to exemplarily observe the Constitution, laws, and carry out the act of people's democracy. He must do this voluntarily, personally for himself and at the same time for everyone, if he wants to have the opportunity to earn the resource for quality well-being, to be spiritually free, happy, and protected. The act of people's democracy is an understanding of the function of the state, a proposal for improving this function with a personal idea and support for the actions of public organizations with the goal of realizing projects for improving the functionality of the state. It is very important that society transfers to the elective power and the state not powers, but functional tasks, having to influence primarily the functions of the state machine. P. S. Ukrainian society, unfortunately, is not ready to understand the vital importance of a true people's democracy and even less so can it organize itself in this way. Many of us will not read this text to the end or will perceive it as the author's fantasy. But some will understand and truly become imbued with the idea of changing the political system with the help of people's democracy. This will mean that state-building Prosvita is needed by Ukrainians and will bear its fruit.
«Слово Просвіти», CC BY 4.0; machine translation from Ukrainian by Prosvita.Digital · PDF auf Wikimedia Commons ↗ · Maschinelle Übersetzung
