Page · p. 12original page ↗
Film Heroes: The Power of Influence
Слово Просвіти, №06 за 2012 рік
Larysa BRYUKHOVETSKA, editor-in-chief of the Kino-Teatr magazine, head of the Center for Cinematographic Studies at the National University of Kyiv-Mohyla Academy. Cinema is a potent means of influence and, depending on whose hands it is in, it can bring good and benefit, or it can be evil and cause harm. In Ukraine, there prevails a total indifference toward low-quality screen products, in which violence and cruelty are cultivated, and which have flooded the Ukrainian film market since the late 1980s (one of the Russian filmmakers in the early 90s remarked: when the Iron Curtain fell, instead of quality cinema, they opened the tap of a "sewer pipe" for us...). Our neighbors — Poland and Russia — chose the right line in protecting their film space: not bans, but competition with the Hollywood product; they release films of their own production, reflect the lives of their citizens and the history of their country in them, and adapt their literature for the screen (in December of last year, a record cinema attendance was recorded in Russia — viewers went to see the film "Vysotsky: Thank You for Being Alive," and here is a very fresh report: filming has begun for a movie based on F. Dostoevsky's novel "Demons"). What the situation with Ukrainian cinema has been for twenty years is well known. Meanwhile, a circle of fighters "against censorship" has emerged in Ukraine, who, instead of supporting Ukrainian cinema, stand in defense of cinematic imports and assure that "dirty films" have no negative influence on the viewer, particularly on teenagers, and that cruelty on screen is not related to the increase of such negative phenomena among youth as crime, drunkenness, and other misfortunes. The reasons for such a situation lie not only in the state's indifference to its own cinema, but also in the fact that no one has engaged in or even been interested in the sociology of film research in Ukraine.
Gilbert Cohen-Séat, in his work “Problems of Cinema and Visual Information,” published in Paris in 1961, wrote about cinematography: “Instead of being subordinate to some norms and the spirit of culture and civilization, it represents, on a collective level, a chaos of social and cultural levels, and on an individual level, a factor of psychological disturbances, the power of influence of which is still little studied, but undeniable. From an anthropological point of view, the question of the conditions of life of the mind is raised.” Cinema (and television following it) can be compared to a voluntary captivity into which humanity has fallen at the present stage. The quality of that screen life is a separate issue. For now, let us abstract from evaluations and focus on the mechanism of its perception and influence. As we can see, half a century ago science recorded the fact of the influence of cinema on human consciousness, the nature of which, and even more so the consequences, are little studied. There are many reasons and motivations for why people watch films. Based on which films are the most popular, they are watched mainly for entertainment. Researchers have drawn attention to the “escape from reality,” which society has legalized in cinema as a phenomenon of mass culture. The “film-viewer” relationship is studied by the sociology of cinema. In the USSR, sociological research in this area was conducted, but it was generally reduced to determining the popularity of a film and an attempt to understand what its secret was. The scientific interests of foreign scholars were broader: they sought to find out how the influence of a film on the viewer occurs. The object of research became the viewer's psyche. The psychological action of cinema is revealed by the theory of the French researcher Edgar Morin — one of the most famous representatives of the sociology of cinema in France, author of the book “The Cinema, or The Imaginary Man.” The central problem of his research is the study of how the viewer perceives a film and the process of projection-identification directly related to this. This process belongs to mental states that are also encountered in everyday life. Every person projects their subjective “self” onto objective reality. Identification occurs under different circumstances, including when a person says: “If I were in his place...”. The foundation of a film, as is known, is a photographic image. Morin reminds us of the special status of photography in our culture — it plays the role of a fetish in sensual relationships, is undeniable evidence in an investigation, certifies human identity, and sometimes supernatural properties are attributed to it (the ability to register metaphysical phenomena inaccessible to the human eye; representatives of some primitive cultures believed that a taken photograph would deprive them of their soul). But the peculiarity of the photographic image is not an objective fact; it arises as a result of the effect of the work of human thought, which found in film and photography a privileged space for the manifestation of the human double, a kind of peculiar combination of the features of a shadow and a mirror. By the way, the assertion that what is seen on the screen must be enriched by one's own imagination was expressed by the American philosopher Hugo Münsterberg in the book “The Photoplay: A Psychological Study” back in 1916. Such is the nature of cinematography — it creates an illusion of lifelikeness. This very quickly made it an art that has great power of influence. But what allows the viewer to exist within it is not so much the similarity of the cinematographic spectacle to objective reality as the subjective sensual identification of the viewer with the cinematographic image. Why does this become possible? According to Morin, the subjective emotional participation of the viewer in the action of the film seems to transform screen events into something that actually exists. This happens thanks to the special conditions that prevail in the cinema hall, as well as thanks to the cinematographic means of expression. All means of film language serve this process, but primarily movement and close-ups. The close-up allows one to become a participant in the cinematographic performance. As for movement in cinema, it has a multidimensional character: besides the movement of characters on the screen, the movement of the camera, there exists the dynamism of music, rhythm, editing, and the flow of time that passes during the viewing. It is precisely thanks to their disposition that a cinema viewer can be in two places at once — in the world shown in the film and in the cinema hall. The situation of the viewer in the cinema hall, Morin believes, is a very important factor — it is precisely what decisively causes projection-identification so intensely. This is primarily influenced by the darkness in the hall, the immobility of the viewer, and their involvement in the action. Darkness deepens the viewer's participation in the events of the film, and their passivity leads to greater emotional vulnerability. Thus, practical reality in cinema is reduced to emotional reality. Cinematographic means take the viewer captive, thanks to which the film (“a machine for projection-identification,” as Morin called it) performs partial work instead of the viewer's psyche. Because of this, the viewer does not have to exert effort to identify with the image. Thanks to the peculiarities of the film's language and the conditions in the cinema hall, they immediately get the impression that they are among the world being shown. Moreover, what they are watching is loaded with emotions. Taking all these circumstances into account, Morin outlines the film as a “radioactive engine, stuffed with projections-identifications,” or as an effect of a “molecular explosion” of the cinematographic image, saturated with sensuality. Thus, it is an undeniable fact that screen images are reflected in the psyche and consciousness of a person. Moreover, it is about finding one's alter ego in the hero of the film, which provides the ground for imitation. The viewer can liken themselves to the heroes of the film and imitate them. The very choice of a model for imitation occurs for various reasons: it can be the physical or moral similarity of the viewer to the hero; the viewer can find features of a loved one in the hero, and finally, the character embodies the viewer's human ideal. Yes, everything in a film is foreseen and calculated for perception. Of course, everyone perceives in their own way: no matter how this process is programmed in a film, it is always perceived individually, although collective emotions are formed in the hall, which to a certain extent influence the perception of each viewer.
Half a century has passed since the aforementioned studies by French scientists. Cinematography has changed, it has become more technologized, and in terms of audience mass, it has been noticeably pushed aside by television. The nature of perception has also changed: films are watched mainly at home on a small screen, and not in a cinema hall. So how does cinema influence the viewer today, given the outlined changes? To this end, I conducted a written survey among students who are taking my course “History of Cinema. Humanistic Concepts” at the National University of Kyiv-Mohyla Academy, in which 31 respondents took part. It was necessary to answer two questions: “Which film characters correspond to the values that are important to you?” and “What are the reasons for imitating a film hero?”. Honestly, when I proposed these questions, I did not expect to receive such a wide spectrum of opinions, and meaningful and thoughtful ones at that. Three participants fundamentally objected to imitating film heroes as such (“I do not consider it necessary to imitate heroes.” “I do not imitate film heroes because I do not end up in similar stories.” “I have never imitated film heroes, but in my opinion, quite a lot of people do this because of their complexes and far-fetched flaws”). Such statements can be interpreted as a lack of heroes worthy of imitation in the films that these respondents watched. There were answers in which attempts were made to determine the reasons for imitation. This, in particular, is self-doubt — “such a person looks for ideal traits to imitate in a film hero.” The reason for imitation can also be the small life experience of a person who has not yet found themselves. “A person is always in search, watching films, analyzing them and finding their own image for themselves, they can look at some problem from the side and solve the issues that interest them.” The answers express thoughts about what fascinates them in the films they have seen, as well as which heroes are worthy of imitation. For example: “one can imitate a hero if he embodies the image of a worthy, decent person, does good and does not succumb to temptations.” They like films that have a deep emotional moral subtext, in which human moral virtues are revealed (“Gandhi” by R. Attenborough, “Dolls” by Takeshi Kitano), sensual films that prompt one to think about certain life situations. Some like films where one can analyze the negative actions of heroes, and some are impressed by historical films, where “the problem of choice is depicted in the best possible way. Satisfy your own interests or think about the interests of your family or even the country? This question is still relevant today. Watching films about historical events, you can clearly see the advantages and disadvantages of one or another decision.” The answers allow us to draw a portrait of a film hero whom modern students want to imitate. “An extraordinary, free-thinking, creative personality, but, unlike many film ‘originals’, he is neither a closed marginal nor an egoistic snob. He has enough courage not only to go his own way, but also to teach others to do so.” “Unusual characters, humane.” “Heroes are sincere and frank, who are not afraid of society’s judgment, perform miracles with their own efforts, and this is what is missing in life.” “A strong-spirited, self-confident person, for whom self-development and improvement are characteristic, an organized person.” “Altruistic, sacrificial in relation to other people, devoted to society for the sake of its preservation and improvement.” It is not worth being surprised that some are impressed by the heroes of the film “The Dreamers” by Bernardo Bertolucci, which tells about the events of the late 1960s: “the image of rebellious youth, free ideas, the beauty of the human body, their feeling of the world, art, each other, their reflections on politics, life.” They did not ignore Johnny Depp in “Pirates of the Caribbean” “as the embodiment of an easy attitude to everything and the ability to joke in the most difficult situation.” It is comforting that the respondents also watch film classics, in particular films by François Truffaut, Federico Fellini, Frank Capra. “A hero who surprised me is Montag from Ray Bradbury’s novel and the film of the same name ‘Fahrenheit 451’, who was brave enough to change his life and rebel against the system. Although this situation is hyperbolized in the film, the moral is clear.” To the heroes who
«Слово Просвіти», CC BY 4.0; machine translation from Ukrainian by Prosvita.Digital · PDF on Wikimedia Commons ↗ · Machine translation
