Емблема «Просвіта»Prosvita.DigitalWiedza · Ludzie · Przyszłość
Strona · s. 1strona oryginału ↗

Obscene Pleasures of Power: Reflections of a Philosopher

Слово Просвіти, №41 за 2011 рік

Oleksii SHEVCHENKO, Doctor of Philosophy O tempora, o moris! (O the times, o the customs!) Cicero I was prompted to write these notes by the events of recent months, which mark the beginning of a systematic "cleansing" of the opposition and a real threat of reviving the most loathsome features of our comparatively recent past. My main goal is to try to understand what is happening to us, and in doing so to avoid worn-out characterizations such as "authoritarianism," "totalitarianism," and "dictatorship." I want to analyze the "abyss" into which we are now sliding from a somewhat unusual angle: from the standpoint of the metaphysics of morality. The logic on which I rely in my choice is very simple. Behind every socio-political phenomenon stand concrete performers: people with a certain psychotype, a system of values (or, under our conditions, "concepts"), an intellectual horizon, and cultural preferences. If we are talking about openly undemocratic regimes (although this is a hackneyed word), then to the characteristics mentioned above one must add a description of the characteristic deviations of these people. On this point I fully agree with Erich Fromm that at the origins of such regimes there are always deviants: pathological narcissists, sadists, necrophiles, maniacs, and paranoids of power. It is about these phenomena that I want to speak, because I am convinced that the anatomy of this human destructiveness can clarify a great deal about the general, ever-deepening degradation of "morality" of which we are witnesses. Where does the term "obscene pleasures" itself come from, a term that, I believe, is key to understanding the essence of this destructiveness? For the record, I will say that this term was aptly used by the very popular Slovenian philosopher and cultural psychoanalyst Slavoj Žižek to explain the features of the political regimes mentioned above. Continuing the line of E. Fromm (though without referring to him) in the study of social psychopathology, he brings into the orbit of his research the dimensions of Desire and Pleasure, which in one way or another are connected with Violence and inevitably accompany all "directions of power." Briefly summarizing the essence of Žižek's ideas on the connection between pleasure and violence, the following can be said. If such violence is formalized and rigidly regulated by institutions and legal norms (as in democratic states), then the share of possible perverse satisfactions for people is reduced to a controlled minimum. (Although no political system can by itself protect against the emergence of such deviations. Let us recall the torture at the Guantanamo prison.) However, there is a type of society in which such pleasure is in fact legalized. According to Žižek, this is "totalitarianism," characterized by total psychopathology, which the authorities have made almost an obligation for both executioners and victims. The characteristic of "obscenity" that inevitably accompanies all scenarios of Desire under this type of regime is associated with the destruction of customary norms: institutional, legal, moral, and religious. In turn, such destruction provokes a powerful release of dark energy and creates an atmosphere of celebrating freedom from all former restrictions. Within the context of this scenario of Desire, German fascism and Soviet Stalinism are related not merely by the scale of violence but also by the explosion of obscenity that accompanies this violence. So as not to weary the reader with an account of this theory of totalitarianism, somewhat unusual for political science, I want to fix at once in consciousness the thesis that after 2010 we began to live under the sign of the said obscenity, and that the Stalinist "whiff" which literally hangs in the air and permeates landmark political events (primarily the trials of Yurii Lutsenko and Yulia Tymoshenko) follows directly from the legalization of obscenity on a nationwide scale, from the total mockery of destroyed institutions, norms, and principles of humanity. It is by this "orgiastic" character in the affirmation of Evil that the new regime differs from the creeping, dim, bureaucratic-anal authoritarianism of Leonid Kuchma. I recall my first impression of encountering this obscenity. After the victory in the 2010 elections, the winners staged a almost two-week orgy at Lesi Ukrainky Square (near the CEC). Throughout this period, the dark-clad, drunken Donetsk lumpens walked through Pecherske like conquistadors to whom the city (the majority of whose population, by the way, had rejected their candidate) had been handed over for plunder. It was a true "festival of blackness." Deafening music thundered, and from the loudspeakers came the same hysterical cries about the victory of Viktor Yanukovych, which so resembled the German "Heil!" I involuntarily compared the feeling of this orgy with the feelings that filled me during the Orange Revolution, when people had bright faces and everyone naively believed in the coming of a utopian era of "Kingdom Continued on page 2

«Слово Просвіти», CC BY 4.0; machine translation from Ukrainian by Prosvita.Digital · PDF w Wikimedia Commons ↗ · Tłumaczenie maszynowe

Емблема «Просвіта»Prosvitianyn