Сторінка · с. 2сторінка оригіналу ↗
Holodomor as Genocide of 1932–1933 in Ukraine
Слово Просвіти, №46 за 2013 рік
Petro CHERNEHA, Head of the Department of Ethnology and Regional Studies at the Institute of Historical Education of the Mykhailo Drahomanov National Pedagogical University, Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor
Three holodomors in Ukraine, organized by the communist regime in 1921–1922, 1932–1933 and 1946–1947, total Russification, and mass measures of Party and Soviet bodies of a political and economic character aimed at dissolving the Ukrainian people into the Russian one, have vividly confirmed the prophecy of Taras Shevchenko: "Where there is no sacred freedom, there will never be goodness." The holodomor in Ukraine of 1932–1933, deliberately organized by the Stalinist regime, belongs to the most brutal and largest acts of genocide known to humanity. The specter of communism brought famine with it from the first days of building the new society. The organizers of the famine on the territory of the fallen Russian Empire were the Bolsheviks led by V. Ulianov (Lenin). This was a policy of state terror, the main means of building a communist society on the ruins of the empire. The grain procurement crisis of 1928–1929 and the Bolsheviks' transition to a policy of liquidating well-off peasants (kulaks) as a class, which Stalin announced on December 27, 1929, in a report at a scientific conference of Marxist agrarians, again placed war-communist methods of management on the agenda. As a result of the new authorities' repressions in 1928–1931 alone, the number of peasant households decreased by 352 thousand; in 1917 there had been about 4,224 thousand of them. In reality, the number of ruined peasant households was much larger, and the so-called kulaks had already been liquidated by the Bolsheviks during 1918–1919. The causes of the Holodomor-genocide of the Ukrainian people in 1932–1933 are of a doctrinal nature. They proceed from the programmatic principles of Marxism-Leninism. The main cause is the agrarian policy of the Bolsheviks at the turn of the 1920s and 1930s. Undoubtedly, the idea of collective farm construction stems from the food requisitioning (prodrozverstka), from the ideology and practice of war communism, by the application of which the Bolsheviks decided the problem of holding power and fighting counterrevolution. The idea of creating kolkhozes and sovkhozes, Stalin would say, was launched by us already during the October Coup: "The Party foresaw their necessity, and this was reflected in the program of the RKP(b), adopted at the VIII Congress in March 1919."
The Bolsheviks established real control over agricultural production from the first days of seizing power by means of land departments, committees of the poor, and communes. The central organ of the RKP(b), the newspaper "Pravda," commenting on the resolution of the congress of the above-named bodies and economies "On the Collectivization of Agriculture" (January 1919), reported that the new forms "will inevitably lead to a single communist organization of all agriculture." The Bolsheviks well knew the history of governing society by means of plundering and distributing food products. And this is not surprising, since the food problem became the main one from the first days of Soviet power. The peasant did not want to hand over grain for free, to work exclusively for grain procurement. A different matter was labor in a kolkhoz under the command of a brigadier and chairman and under the supervision of punitive organs. The results of such labor were collective (state) and could be centrally removed beyond the limits of the artel. Thus, the socialization of agricultural production was recognized by the Party as the main and most effective method of collecting the food requisition and of grain procurement in general. In the totalitarian system of Bolshevik power there was no place for independence as a category of human behavior. The peasant-owner, the peasant-producer was independent; he fed his family and the state. He stood in the way of collectivization; to destroy him, it was necessary to organize famine. Was the holodomor in Ukraine a planned action, or was it caused by the necessity of plundering the peasants to extract funds for industrialization? Not only that! The fertile Ukrainian land and the hardworking, multimillion-strong peasantry, and the geopolitical and strategic position of Ukraine, extremely advantageous for creating a new Soviet empire, were for Stalin the main precondition and the real proof that, once Ukraine was subdued, his variant of socialism would triumph, a powerful base of material and human resources for building the Soviet empire and the subsequent realization of the idea of world proletarian revolution. Industrialization was an important component of Lenin's plan for building communism, while the peasantry, according to Lenin, was its main enemy, a "petty-bourgeois element." The peasant is reactionary and backward, the leaders of the Bolsheviks repeatedly stated in their declarations. "The peasant sea is spontaneous," Stalin said, "and on a mass scale gives birth to capitalism, and therefore it must be destroyed." In 1928 Stalin and his associates decided to force the industrialization of the country at the expense of the peasants: they lowered procurement prices for grain and at the same time rapidly raised the prices of industrial goods supplied to the countryside; exorbitant and diverse taxes on peasants, entrepreneurs and artisans grew rapidly; the volume of industrial goods decreased, while prices rose considerably. Already from 1928 peasants began to starve; they began to hide grain from the state. The regime faced a choice: either war with the peasantry, or driving it into kolkhozes and sovkhozes and seizing its grain there. By alienating peasants from the land and from the distribution of the product they produced, to turn them into serfs of Soviet power. The Ukrainian village, according to the Law on the Unified Agricultural Tax, for 1930–1931 was subjected to the highest tax in the USSR on the scale of profitability set by the authorities. The profitability norms per hectare of arable land, sown field and meadows for Ukraine amounted to 40, 58 and 26 rubles respectively. For the Russian SFSR they were 37, 46 and 16 rubles. In certain regions of Ukraine they were considerably higher. The enserfment of peasants by the state took place in the shortest possible time. The CC VKP(b), by its resolution of January 5, 1930, planned to complete collectivization in the autumn of 1930 or the spring of 1931, and the First Secretary of the CC CP(b)U, Kosior, adopted a "counter-plan" to complete this matter by the autumn of 1930. Ukraine stood on the threshold of civil war. According to data of the HPU, from February 20 to April 2, 1930 alone, 1,716 mass uprisings of peasants took place against collectivization, 15 of them armed. And over the year there were already more than 4 thousand of them, with the participation of over 1.2 million people. Their main slogan was the demand for the restoration of an independent Ukrainian state and the liquidation of communist farms in the village.
The Communist authorities brutally suppressed the resistance of insurgent peasants in Ukraine. In 1932–1933 the State Political Directorate arrested about 200 thousand people, who were tried, sent to prisons, and exiled to the eastern regions of the USSR. Pavlo Shtepa, citing V. Holub's work "Konspektyvnyi narys istorii KPU" ("Summary Outline of the History of the CPU"), asserts that immediately after the abolition of the New Economic Policy in 1929 and during collectivization, the Stalinist regime repressed and deported from Ukraine 1.2 million so-called kulaks, while in 1932 alone it brought over 200 thousand Communists, Komsomol members, and employees of the security organs from the central and western oblasts of Russia into Ukrainian towns and villages. The All-Union Resettlement Committee of the Council of People's Commissars of the USSR sent 329 trainloads to the lands of Ukraine devastated by the Holodomor by the end of 1933, carrying the property and livestock of 21,856 households and 117,149 members of their families from Gorky, Ivanovo, and other oblasts. The agrarian policy of the Bolsheviks drained the productive forces of Ukraine's agriculture. In 1930, of 22.9 million tons of grain harvested, 7.8 million tons were confiscated from the peasants. In 1931, 17.6 million tons were harvested, and 6.9 million tons were taken away. Of the gross harvest of 1932, which amounted to 12.8 million tons, 7 million tons were seized. Only seed grain was left. The Ukrainian village was left without bread. During 1932–1933 the USSR exported over 2.8 million tons of grain to Western Europe, mostly from Ukrainian peasants. The Stalinist regime continues to form the state food reserve in kind (grain, vegetables, fruit, pickled goods, etc.) through coercion, plunder, and repression. In the autumn of 1932, 112 thousand Party and Soviet activists and NKVD employees were sent to Ukraine to forcibly seize food products from the peasants. About 50% of what was plundered went to them. The peasants responded by leaving the collective farms. In the first half of 1932 alone, the number of collectivized farms in Ukraine fell by 41.2 thousand. In January of that same year, about 127 thousand people fled to the cities. Up to 40% of the collective farm arable land in 1932–1933 became so overgrown with weeds that they choked the rye, wheat, and other grain crops.
Photo by Oleksandr Lytvynenko
The authorities reduced the household plots of collective farmers to a minimum, in order to force them to seek a livelihood exclusively through work on the collective farm field. The First Secretary of the CC CP(b)U, P. Postyshev, one of the principal executors of the will of the supreme executioner Stalin, declared in February 1933: "The best measure of the quality of agricultural leadership were and are grain procurements." Collectivization and grain procurement were accompanied by repressions and mass killings of peasants and their children by punitive organs, representatives of local authorities, and activists. The struggle of the Ukrainian peasantry against collectivization and against the establishment of Bolshevik order manifested itself in mass flights of peasants to the cities, withdrawals from collective farms, and uprisings against the authorities, which often took the form of armed resistance. To prevent the peasants from fleeing to the cities, as well as to control their movement and keep personal records of the entire population of the USSR, the authorities introduced a passport regime and the institution of residence registration (propiska) in 1932. Peasants were not issued passports, and their departure from the village to the city for work and residence was permitted only with the permission of the collective farm leadership and district authorities. In this way the state established total control over society, and for the peasants a new form of serfdom. On 7 August 1932 the CEC and the Council of People's Commissars of the USSR adopted a law on the protection of state property, written by Stalin in his own hand, under which theft of the harvest, livestock, etc. was punished by execution with confiscation of property, while minor thefts (gathering ears of grain, a handful of grain) were punished by imprisonment for 10 years, even for children from the age of 12. In order to finally stop the peasants' flight from famine and to eliminate their resistance, the Bolshevik authorities in December 1932 placed on the "blacklist" villages "that maliciously sabotage grain procurement," and on 22 January 1933 Stalin personally wrote a directive letter of the CC VKP(b) and the Council of People's Commissars of the USSR, which documented the Kremlin's intention, by means of confiscating any foodstuffs and banning the departure of peasants from Ukraine and Kuban to other regions, to organize a mass famine of Ukrainian grain growers. At the end of the 1920s, there were about 916 thousand ethnic Ukrainians in Kuban, which constituted over 70% of the region's population; in the North Caucasus there were 3.2 million, and in the Volga region over 600 thousand. Millions of peasants became victims of these draconian laws. The blockade of their settlements by troops and the total plunder of their farms completed the Bolsheviks' implementation of the plan to organize the Holodomor in Ukraine. Mass starvation of peasants engulfed all 55 thousand Ukrainian villages from the spring of 1931 and lasted until the winter of 1934. It was accompanied by the murders of adults and children, cannibalism, and suicide. Cannibalism took on a mass and horrific character. In Ukraine 10 thousand court cases against cannibals were registered, but they do not reveal the scale of this terrible social phenomenon. Children suffered especially, making up over 38% of the rural population. In every village hundreds of children died of hunger, and they were massively killed by the authorities for gathering in
«Слово Просвіти», CC BY 4.0; machine translation from Ukrainian by Prosvita.Digital · PDF у Вікісховищі ↗ · Машинний переклад
